Artisan and Award-Winning Cheese

Artisan mature cheddar cheese selection from the UK by Online Cheesemonger, perfect for cheese boards with blue cheese, brie and soft cheese.

Cheddar

12 products

  • View
  • View

12 products

Artisan Cheddar Cheese

Explore artisan cheddar from Scottish and British cheesemakers, from mature farmhouse styles to smoked and flavoured cheeses. Try Isle of Mull Cheddar or St Andrews Farmhouse Cheddar.

Cheddar for Cheeseboards & Cooking

Cheddar gives a cheeseboard a firm, savoury foundation. Compare it with creamy Brie, characterful Blue Cheese and our wider Hard Cheese range.

What to Serve with Cheddar

Add Scottish oatcakes, chutneys and pickles or charcuterie. Read our Cheddar Cheese Guide and Complete Cheeseboard Guide.

Cheddar Gifts

For ready-made pairings, browse our cheese selections and gift sets.

Why Choose Artisan Cheddar?

Artisan cheddar can vary considerably in texture and flavour. Younger cheeses may be smoother and gentler, while longer-matured farmhouse cheeses can become firmer, more savoury and complex. Scottish cheddar also gives you the chance to explore distinctive regional producers rather than treating cheddar as a single uniform style.

For a simple three-cheese board, use cheddar as the firm element, then add a creamy cheese and a blue. If you are serving a larger group, introduce goat’s or washed-rind cheese rather than adding several very similar cheddars.

Cheddar Cheese FAQs

What goes well with cheddar cheese?

Oatcakes, savoury biscuits, chutney, pickles, fruit and charcuterie all work well. Match the strength of the accompaniment to the maturity of the cheddar.

What is the difference between mature and extra mature cheddar?

The terms generally indicate increasing maturation and flavour intensity, although exact ageing and character vary by producer. Check each individual cheese for its specific style.

Is cheddar good for a cheeseboard?

Yes. Its firm texture makes it an excellent foundation alongside Brie-style cheese, blue cheese and contrasting accompaniments.

How much cheddar do I need per person?

Think about the total cheese being served rather than allocating a full portion of every cheese to every guest. See our cheese portion guide for practical ranges.

How should cheddar be stored?

Follow the storage instructions supplied with the individual cheese and keep it refrigerated where required. Good wrapping helps prevent the cut surface from drying out.

© 2026 Online Cheesemonger, Powered by Shopify

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Maestro
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Union Pay
  • Visa